When it comes to powerful cordless impact wrenches, two brands, Milwaukee and Makita, consistently dominate the market. The Milwaukee 2967-20 and Makita XWT08Z are two such tools that are often compared due to their impressive capabilities, professional-grade performance, and user-friendly features. This article will take a deep dive into each tool, comparing their specifications, performance, design, and more, helping you make an informed decision for your next tool purchase.
Overview of the Tools
Milwaukee 2967-20
The Milwaukee 2967-20 is part of the company’s M18 Fuel line, renowned for its cordless power tools. This impact wrench is a heavy-duty, high-torque tool designed for both professionals and serious DIY enthusiasts. Milwaukee’s M18 Fuel technology combines a powerful motor, advanced electronics, and long-lasting batteries to deliver superior performance.
Key Features:
- High Torque: With up to 1,400 ft-lbs of nut-busting torque, the 2967-20 is capable of handling tough fastenings in automotive, construction, and heavy equipment tasks.
- Compact Design: Despite its high power, the tool has a compact body (just 8.3 inches long), allowing for better maneuverability in tight spaces.
- Redlink Plus Intelligence: This feature provides advanced protection against overloads and overheating, ensuring the tool performs optimally and prolonging battery life.
- All-weather Performance: The Milwaukee 2967-20 is built to perform in extreme weather conditions, making it an excellent choice for outdoor or job-site use in varying climates.
Makita XWT08Z
On the other hand, the Makita XWT08Z is a part of Makita’s LXT series, designed to deliver high performance with their advanced 18V lithium-ion battery system. This impact wrench has earned a reputation for reliability, ergonomics, and robust power, making it a favorite among professionals in various industries.
Key Features:
- High Torque: The XWT08Z delivers up to 1,400 ft-lbs of fastening torque and 1,800 ft-lbs of nut-busting torque, which makes it incredibly powerful for heavy-duty applications.
- Brushless Motor: The tool is powered by Makita’s brushless motor, which increases efficiency and provides a longer tool life by reducing wear and tear.
- Compact Design: Similar to the Milwaukee model, the Makita XWT08Z also features a compact design at just 8.3 inches long, making it ideal for use in confined spaces.
- Variable Speed Trigger: The XWT08Z is equipped with a variable speed trigger, allowing users to have precise control over their work, enhancing its versatility.
Performance Comparison
Power and Torque
Both the Milwaukee 2967-20 and Makita XWT08Z pack a punch when it comes to power and torque. While both tools offer 1,400 ft-lbs of fastening torque, the Makita takes the lead in nut-busting torque with an impressive 1,800 ft-lbs compared to Milwaukee’s 1,400 ft-lbs. This makes the Makita a better option for users looking to tackle particularly tough, rusted, or stuck fasteners.
However, in most applications, both tools offer more than enough power to handle demanding tasks. Whether you’re working on automotive repairs, construction, or heavy machinery, these wrenches will provide the muscle needed to get the job done.
Battery and Run Time
The Milwaukee 2967-20 operates on Milwaukee’s M18 battery platform, while the Makita XWT08Z uses the LXT 18V battery. Both brands have a well-established reputation for providing long-lasting, high-capacity batteries. However, Milwaukee’s Redlithium batteries are known for offering extended run-time and better performance in cold weather conditions, while Makita’s LXT series boasts a high level of efficiency and quick-charging times.
While battery life is influenced by usage, these tools perform well under most conditions, providing adequate run-time for most tasks. Milwaukee’s Redlink Plus system also protects the tool from overheating and over-discharge, further improving battery longevity.
Speed and Control
Both impact wrenches come with multiple speed settings to offer optimal control. The Milwaukee 2967-20 features four different speed and torque settings, allowing users to adjust the tool to match specific tasks, while the Makita XWT08Z comes with a 3-speed power selection button for fast, efficient operation.
The Makita’s variable-speed trigger adds to its versatility, offering more precise control over speed. However, the Milwaukee’s pre-programmed modes might be better for users who need quick and easy adjustments without fiddling with the trigger.
Durability and Design
Milwaukee 2967-20
The Milwaukee 2967-20 is built with durability in mind. The tool’s rugged construction ensures it can withstand heavy use on job sites and in demanding environments. Its housing is designed to be resistant to impact, dust, and debris, contributing to its long lifespan. Additionally, the ergonomic grip on the 2967-20 is made to reduce hand fatigue, ensuring that users can work for extended periods without discomfort.
Makita XWT08Z
Makita’s XWT08Z is similarly designed for tough environments. It features a protective rubberized grip, which not only enhances comfort but also reduces vibrations, making it easier to control the tool for longer durations. The tool is also equipped with an integrated LED light to help illuminate work areas in low-light conditions.
Both tools are similarly sized and easy to maneuver, despite their high torque outputs, which is a testament to their smart design.
Price and Value
When it comes to pricing, the Milwaukee 2967-20 tends to be more expensive than the Makita XWT08Z. This price difference often reflects the advanced features in the Milwaukee’s M18 Fuel line, which includes the Redlink Plus Intelligence and better protection systems for extended tool life. However, the Makita XWT08Z still offers excellent value with its powerful brushless motor and efficient battery system, making it an excellent choice for users looking for a high-performing, well-rounded tool at a lower price.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both the Milwaukee 2967-20 and Makita XWT08Z are excellent impact wrenches that can handle a wide range of heavy-duty applications. Here are some factors to consider when choosing between the two:
- Power and Torque: If your work requires exceptional nut-busting torque, the Makita XWT08Z edges ahead with 1,800 ft-lbs. However, for most users, both tools will provide sufficient power.
- Battery Life: The Milwaukee 2967-20 has an edge when it comes to cold weather performance and extended battery life, thanks to its Redlithium battery technology.
- Control and Versatility: If you value having multiple preset speed and torque settings, the Milwaukee tool offers more customization options. On the other hand, the Makita XWT08Z’s variable-speed trigger gives you more manual control over the speed.
- Price and Value: The Makita XWT08Z is typically more affordable, offering great value for users looking for reliability without breaking the bank.
Conclusion
Both the Milwaukee 2967-20 and Makita XWT08Z are powerful and reliable impact wrenches designed for professionals and serious DIYers alike. Choosing between the two comes down to personal preference, specific job requirements, and budget. If you want advanced features, durability, and extended battery life, the Milwaukee 2967-20 might be the right tool for you. However, if you’re looking for a more affordable yet still powerful option with a brushless motor, the Makita XWT08Z will not disappoint.
No matter your choice, either of these tools will serve you well for years to come, offering exceptional performance and reliability in demanding work environments.
